Posted in

Where to sell traditional toys?

If you’re a traditional toys supplier like I am—someone who spent years chasing down cedarwood for wooden pull-along animals or sourcing hand-painted tin soldiers from family-owned workshops in small towns—you’ve probably asked yourself this question a hundred times: Where exactly do you sell these things, instead of letting them collect dust in a warehouse that’s way too big for the line of wooden block sets I designed to fit in a kid’s backpack? I didn’t always have this problem, to be honest. Back when I first started, I sold almost everything at local craft fairs and the annual town festival, where a grandma would stop to tell me the wooden rocking horse I made looked exactly like the one her grandson had when he was little, and a group of moms would snap up all the fabric doll cradle sets I brought because the plastic ones from big-box stores had chipped edges within a week. But after the pandemic, those in-person spots just… stopped working. The crowds shrank, and the people who were there mostly wanted cheap, fast toys made in countries I’d never heard of, not the kind I spend three weeks sanding just right. So I started digging—talking to other small toy makers, asking my customers why they’d stopped coming to the fairs, even messaging a few former clients who’d bought cases of my stacking rings for their kids’ playrooms. What I found was that selling traditional toys isn’t just about “putting them somewhere people will see”—it’s about meeting people where their values are, because the people who care about traditional toys don’t just want a toy. They want something that doesn’t feel disposable, that has a story, that doesn’t require batteries. Let me break down the places that have actually worked for me, and the ones that flopped hard, so you don’t have to waste time like I did. Traditional Toys

First, small, independent specialty stores. I can’t stress this enough—skip the big-box chains. They have buyers that focus on fast turnover, low prices, and inventory that sells 5,000 units a month, not the 20 wooden train sets I make in a batch, each with a little mark of my workshop on the bottom. I started reaching out to independent toy stores that are part of the Toy Association’s Independent Toy Retailer Network a couple years ago, and that’s where my sales really picked up. One store in Portland, for example, only stocks toys made by small US-based makers, and their social media is full of stories about the artists behind the products. They placed an order for 12 of my cloth activity cubes, and in three months they restocked twice because every kid who tried one wouldn’t put it down. The key here is to go local first—don’t pitch a store on the other side of the country when there’s one in your own state that already prioritizes handcrafted goods. I brought a sample of my wooden alphabet puzzles to a small store in Ohio, brought the owner a coffee, and told her about how I source the pine from a family forest in Pennsylvania. She didn’t care that my puzzles cost $18 instead of the $10 plastic ones she could get from a wholesaler. She cared that a kid would pass that puzzle down to their sibling, then their cousin, then maybe their own kid. The flop here was a big department store that reached out to me during holiday season a couple years back. They offered me a spot in their seasonal pop-up, but they wanted me to cut my price by 30% and print their logo on every toy. I said no, and later heard from another supplier that they never paid their first batch of invoices. Lesson learned: independent stores care about your story, big chains care about your price.

Next, online marketplaces that prioritize handmade, vintage, or artisanal goods. I tried Amazon first, back in 2020, because everyone told me that’s where people shop. Big mistake. My toys got buried under thousands of plastic and battery-operated ones, and the fees ate into my profits so much I was only making $2 on a $15 wooden dollhouse. Then I switched to Etsy, and that’s been a game-changer. I set up my shop, took photos of my toys next to the cedar trees I use, wrote descriptions that talk about the workshops and the time I spent testing each product (I test every toy myself with my 7-year-old nephew, by the way—if he can’t play with it safely, it doesn’t go up), and suddenly people started finding me. Last year, I sold 80% of my hand-carved wooden animal sets through Etsy, and half of those orders came from people who left a note saying they’d been looking for a toy that didn’t make noise when their kid was trying to sleep. But Etsy isn’t the only option. I also tried Not on the High Street, a UK-based marketplace that connects small makers with shoppers who want unique gifts. I sold a batch of tin soldiers there to a collector in London who said he’d been looking for ones made with the same lead-free metal as his grandfather’s set. The thing about these marketplaces is you have to be specific. Don’t just list “traditional toys”—list “hand-carved wooden pull-along duck, made from sustainably sourced pine, safe for ages 1+”. The shoppers on these platforms are looking for exactly that. The flop here was Facebook Marketplace. I listed a batch of my fabric marionettes there once, and got 10 messages within an hour offering half price, or asking if I’d deliver them for free, or even trying to trade me a broken toy car for one. It was like shooting in the dark. I sold one, but it took a week. Never again.

Then there’s pop-up shops focused on family and heritage. I used to avoid pop-ups because I thought they were just for fashion or home goods, but I did one last year at a heritage festival in my home state, and it was the best move I’ve made in years. The festival was all about keeping local crafts and traditions alive—so the crowd was exactly my people. A lot of grandparents came by, remembering the wooden toys they had as kids, and parents who wanted to give their kids a toy that wasn’t just a screen accessory. I brought a table with all my samples, let kids try out the stacking cups and the pull-along trains, and even did a little demonstration of how I carve the wooden animals. I sold every batch of wooden puzzles I brought that weekend, and got three wholesale orders from other small stores that were there looking for traditional toys. Another pop-up I did was a “family toy swap” event at a community center in Chicago. The organizers reached out because they wanted to add a section of new, small-made traditional toys to the swap, and I joined. It was a smaller crowd, but every person who came was engaged. A mom brought her two kids, who spent 20 minutes playing with my wooden block set, and she ordered five more for her friends’ kids’ birthdays. The key with these pop-ups is to look for ones that have a mission tied to heritage, family, or sustainability—don’t just sign up for a random holiday pop-up that has 50 different vendors selling everything from candles to phone cases. Those events are where people are just browsing, not looking for a specific product. The flop here was a big holiday market at a convention center last December. I paid $500 for a booth, and most of the other vendors were selling cheap jewelry and knit scarves. The crowd was mostly people looking for last-minute gifts, and they didn’t care about a $25 wooden toy when they could get a $10 plastic set at the door. I left with half my toys still in boxes, and no wholesale leads. Never again.

Finally, wholesale to nonprofits and educational organizations. This is a part of the market a lot of toy makers overlook, but it’s been a huge source of steady income for me. I started reaching out to Head Start programs and local elementary schools two years ago, after I heard a teacher say her class only had plastic toys for recess. I offered them bulk discounts for my wooden tabletop games and my fabric activity mats, and I got a big order from a district in upstate New York. They used the toys for their after-school programs, and later told me the kids would rather play with the wooden blocks than any of the electronic educational tools they had. I also worked with a nonprofit that gives toys to kids in foster care. They place orders every quarter, and the best part is I can donate a few extra toys each time, which helps with their tax deductions and makes me feel good, too. The key here is to tailor your pitch to their needs. Schools care about durability and educational value—so tell them how the alphabet puzzles can help with letter recognition, or how the wooden counting beads can teach basic math. Nonprofits care about safety and accessibility—make sure all your toys are lead-free and meet safety standards, and offer bulk pricing that fits their tight budgets. The flop here was a large youth organization that I applied to. They wanted me to give them a 50% discount for a bulk order, but also required me to print their logo on every toy and deliver them for free across the country. I couldn’t afford that, so I passed. It wasn’t worth it.

Now, let’s talk about the things I wish I’d known when I first started looking for places to sell traditional toys. First, tell your story. Every place I’ve had success at—independent stores, Etsy, pop-ups—has wanted to know why you make traditional toys, not just what you make. I have a little bio on my Etsy shop that says I started making toys because my dad, who was a carpenter, would make me wooden soldiers every Christmas when I was a kid. That’s not just fluff—people connect with that. Second, don’t chase every opportunity. When someone offers you a spot somewhere, ask yourself: Do my customers shop here? Will they care about my toys? If the answer is no, walk away. I’ve turned down more offers than I’ve accepted, and that’s okay. Third, test small. When I first reached out to independent stores, I only sent a sample and a small order, not a whole case. That way, if the store didn’t sell, I didn’t lose a lot of money. It builds trust, too—stores are more likely to work with you if you’re not asking for huge orders right away.

Traditional toys aren’t just a product for me. They’re a legacy. I don’t want to see them replaced by disposable plastic that breaks in a week and ends up in a landfill. I want kids to have something they can hold, something that feels real, something that maybe one day they’ll give to their own kids. To do that, though, I need to find places that will help me reach those people— the grandparents, the teachers, the parents, the collectors who know a good toy when they see one. If you’re someone who needs traditional toys for your store, your program, or your family, I’d love to talk. We can work out a bulk order, a wholesale deal, or just chat about what makes these toys special.


Wooden Puzzles References:
The Toy Association. (2023). Independent Retailer Market Report. Toy Industry Association.
Handmade Market Trends 2024. Etsy Inc.
National Association for the Education of Young Children. (2022). Developmentally Appropriate Toys for Early Childhood Classrooms. NAEYC.



Yiwu Hoye Crafts Co., Ltd.
As one of the most professional traditional toys manufacturers and suppliers in China, we also support customized service. Please feel free to wholesale high quality traditional toys for sale here and get pricelist from our factory. For price consultation, contact us.
Address: Room 402, Building 2, Wanti Plaza, Yiwu City, Zhejiang Province, China
E-mail: jennifer@hoye-crafts.com
WebSite: https://www.chinawoodentoyfactory.com/